Skip to content

YouTuber Solves Double Death Cold Case After 21 Years

Remains in a car found at the bottom of a river are presumed to be two teens who went missing in 2000.  

A scuba diver who creates videos showing where he uses sonar technology to find evidence in missing persons cases found a car in a Tennessee river last November linked to two teens who went missing in 2000.

Jeremy Sides’ discovery prompted authorities in White County to reopen the cold case of Erin Foster, 18, and Jeremy Bechtel, 17, who were last seen on April 3, 2000, after leaving Foster’s home, White County Sheriff Steve Page said in a news release. For years, there had been no new evidence in their case.

“The car belonging to a missing woman has been discovered and retained today by the White County Sheriff’s Office. It was pulled from the Calfkiller River today [Dec. 1] and the car has been identified as belonging to the missing woman, Erin Foster, who was reported missing along with Jeremy Bechtel in April 2000,” Page said in an online post.

“I’ve been looking all day and I finally found a car,” Sides says in his video, posted on his YouTube channel Exploring With Nug. The video shows the 1988 Pontiac Grand Am that belonged to Foster.

Police had reportedly looked for the teenagers as far as Florida, but had never found any evidence.

Using a raft equipped with sonar to probe the local rivers, Sides eventually found the car, which was identified through its license plate.

A crane pulls the Pontiac linked to the two missing teens from a river in Tennessee on Dec. 1. (Exploring with Nug/Zenger)

Investigators told WTVF in Nashville that human remains were found in the vehicle, and that they would be sent for testing. Both Foster’s and Bechtel’s families were notified.

The details of how the car ended up in the river are still unknown.

“I’m lost for words. I’m so glad I could find them. I’m so sad that that’s where they ended up. I can’t believe it’s been over 20 years that they’ve been sitting there waiting for someone to find them,” Sides says in his YouTube video.

Sides came to Sparta, Tennessee, to search for Foster’s Pontiac Grand Am.

“It was a very small town, two teenagers go missing and no one knows where they went. Everybody knew these kids, they went to school with them, you know,” Sides told WTVF. “Half the police officers went to school with these guys, they were friends with them.

“It was a very great feeling to bring so much closure and answers to so many people at once. It meant a lot to me and I know it meant a lot to all of them too.”

Recommended from our partners