Skip to content

Opposition Lashes New Zealand Budget, Projections

Opposition leader Judith Collins has hit out at New Zealand's "broken compass" budget, while banks have offered cautious support.

WELLINGTON, New Zealand — New Zealand’s center-right opposition has accused Jacinda Ardern’s government of lacking ambition in the 2021 budget, declaring it a “broken compass budget”.

On May 20, Finance Minister Grant Robertson released the first budget of Labors’ second term — and the first of Jacinda Ardern’s parliamentary majority.

The centerpiece is a boost to social security, with baseline benefits increased immediately by $NZ20 ($14.40) a week in a $NZ3.6 billion ($2.55 billion) four-year splash.

Opposition leader Judith Collins said the lack of tax cuts or incentives showed Labor was about “welfare first and work second”.

Collins tweeted “This is a Broken Compass Budget with no direction for getting the country back on track to prosperity. National would be more aspirational for New Zealanders. We don’t want Kiwis to just exist on a benefit. We want them to have jobs, to prosper and to have a future.”

New Zealand Finance Minister Grant Robertson shows off his budget day tie – a gift from Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern, Parliament House, Wellington, May 20, 2021. (Ben McLay/AAP Image)

“All New Zealanders are feeling the pinch right now — not just those on jobseeker benefits and the minimum wage — so where is the plan to take the entire country back to prosperity?” she asked.

However, Collins said she supported the benefits increase as “we have to at the moment because the cost of living has gone up so much”.

Right-wing party Association of Consumers and Taxpayers took aim at Treasury‘s projections, labeling it a “La La budget because the government is in La La Land”.

“The budget assumes that unemployment will be 4.4 percent and economic growth will be 4.4 percent by 2023,” leader David Seymour said.

Seymour tweeted “Labour is re-writing history. The 1991 Budget cut spending because our country was broke. And we’re going to go broke again under a radical left-wing government that believes it can solve any problem with taxpayer money.”

Opposition has accused Jacinda Ardern’s government of lacking ambition in the 2021 budget, declaring it a “broken compass budget”. (POOL, Newshub, Michael Bradley/AAP Image)

“They are in La La Land. How can that possibly be the case with the Government’s anti-growth, anti-business agenda? We’re heading straight for an iceberg with Grant Robertson at the helm of the ship.”

Banks were more optimistic.

Auckland Savings Bank senior economist Mark Smith said the budget “made all the right noises”, though “a long journey lies ahead”.

“Wisely, the government have not chosen to go down the austerity route and aim to return the books to surplus as quickly as possible,” he said.

“To date there has been little progress in boosting economy-wide productivity, addressing bottlenecks in transport and improving housing affordability.”

The New Zealand’s Exchange50 Index was largely unchanged after the budget, at 12,380 points, while the NZ dollar was also steady, buying 93 Australian cents.

(Edited by Vaibhav Vishwanath Pawar and Praveen Pramod Tewari)

Recommended from our partners