A defunct 4WD hire company that sent its customers intimidating emails has been fined in the Federal Court.
Australian Dodgy Car Company Threatened Customers
GOLD COAST, Australia — A defunct four-wheel-drive hire company that called its customers “absolutely idiotic”, “pathetic”, “delusional”, and threatened to sue them has been fined for breaching Australian consumer law.
One email sent by Australian 4WD Hire to a customer, who was also a magistrate at Australia’s New South Wales, simply read: “F*** off. Kind regards”.
The Federal Court fined the Gold Coast-based company AUD 870,000 ($674,728.05) for unconscionable conduct, misleading statements about insurance coverage, and unfair terms in hire contracts.
Two of its former directors, Vitali Roesch and Maryna Kosukhina, have also been fined a combined AUD 353,000 ($273,613.81).
Australian 4WD Hire, operated by Smart Corporation, went into liquidation in December 2019.
It claimed to offer comprehensive off-road insurance for its 4WDs, between January 2014 and August 2019, when in reality, not all vehicles had comprehensive insurance.
Hiring contracts also left it up to the company to submit an insurance claim or hold the customer liable for the damage.
Contracts were unfair because they included terms allowing customers to be charged up to AUD 500 ($387.5) each time a vehicle was driven in “prohibited” ways.
This included driving at night outside of built-up areas when visibility was poor because of fog or heavy rain.
GPS data tracked when, where and how fast customers drove. The company used this information to prepare driver behavior reports to show customers breached their hiring contracts.
Customers who queried or challenged claims were met with intimidating emails from the fictional persona of Christine Burgess threatening to withhold at least AUD 500 ($387.5) of their security deposits.
“We strongly suggest you stop embarrassing yourself and issue a written apology within 24 hours,” one 2018 email said.
“Your statements are highly defamatory and will not be tolerated, the only dishonest and unreasonable one in this situation is you, and your attempts at commercial extortion are pathetic.
“The points you have made in your email are absolutely idiotic.”
Another customer was in 2017 claimed he got a mail that read, “You must be delusional if you think we would take your word over the certified professionals at our agency.”
“Get a lawyer so I can sue your ass off (sic), you moron,” said the follow-up email by the “Bussines Owner.”
Justice Darren Jackson found such emails sent to 31 customers to allow the company to keep part of all the security bonds for its profit.
“It involved bad faith, deception, unfair pressure, and sharp practice. It included harsh and unjustified threats of legal action and other adverse consequences for the customers which were out of all proportion to any prejudice which A4WD had suffered or would suffer as a result of the customer’s conduct,” the judge said on April 15.
The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, which took the company to court, claimed it received more than 60 complaints between 2016 and April 2019.
(Edited by Vaibhav Vishwanath Pawar and Pallavi Mehra)