VIDEO: Donald Trump Jr. set his sights on big tech months before his father’s feud with Twitter
Months before President Donald Trump signed his May 28 executive order targeting social media platforms, the White House and members of the Trump family were debating how to battle the tech giants.
In an interview with Zenger News on February 28, the president’s eldest son, Donald Trump Jr., raised some of the arguments used against Google and Twitter—months before the president’s announcement and executive order.
Due to technical difficulties the video was not released until now.
Twitter, Google and others should lose federal protections, Trump Jr. said then, if they discriminate against conservatives by censoring, flagging, demonetizing or de-emphasizing their posts, videos or emails.
“People like Google are doing it in Gmail, where they’re inboxing, right? So if the Trump campaign sends an email and the Bernie Sanders campaign sends an email, our email ends up in junk mail. Bernie Sanders is right there at the front of your screen,” he said.
Google spokesperson Riva Sciuto, reached Monday, did not directly deny the Trump allegation, issuing a general statement about how it treats large-scale email senders. Sciuto put the burden on the Trump campaign to make sure the president’s potential donors and other supporters see its emails.
“Irrespective of party affiliation, when large-volume email senders follow our sender guidelines they can better ensure that their emails are received by the intended recipients,” Sciuto said. “Senders can monitor the health of their email sending practices via Postmaster Tools.”
The Trump 2020 campaign hasn’t released any evidence to support the claim that Google is branding its emails to supporters as spam. The campaign did not respond to a request for comment.
In November 2015, a Sanders campaign email triggered Gmail’s “phishing scam” alert. Google put a red warning box at the beginning of a campaign message claiming promises of free college tuition and lower prescription drug prices appeared fraudulent.
“Be careful with this message. It contains content that’s typically used to steal personal information,” the warning box said, linking to a page that said: “This message could be a scam.”
Trump Jr. spoke exclusively to Zenger on video at the Conservative Political Action Conference in National Harbor, Maryland. He hinted at changes to the Communications Decency Act, the law that shields social media platforms from responsibility when their users publish material that could invite lawsuits or criminal prosecutions.
The law’s carve-outs for companies like Twitter, Facebook and Google have the practical effect of giving them safe harbor when their users make statements that would invite legal action if they appeared in a newspaper or a broadcast.
President Trump took precisely that approach with his executive order at the end of last month. While Congress alone can change the law, Attorney General William Barr said at the White House that the Justice Department will seek to sue social media giants in federal court.
His son told Zenger in February that social media platforms should be required to remain politically neutral. Some conservative activists have complained of being “de-platformed” or “shadow banned”—shorthand for overt and covert ways of limiting their ability to communicate freely.
“It’s not free-market when these tech companies have many protections from liability from the U.S. government,” Trump Jr. said. “Once they accept those protections and they cede that liability, which could be plenty, and they’re getting that benefit from the United States government, they lose the ability to say, ‘We can do whatever we want.'”
“You can’t then decide, ‘Well, I only want to protect this class of people,'” he said. “If you tried doing that in any other business you’d be destroyed.”
Trump Jr. said a ban on online political discrimination would be “very comparable” to prohibiting a university from conducting a race-based admissions process if it has access to funds from Pell Grants and other financial aid programs.
He said “people in the Second Amendment movement, people who are pro-religious-liberty, people who are pro-life … [are] the only people that are actually getting censored.”
The president said May 27 in a tweet that Republicans believe social media platforms “totally silence conservatives voices.”
“We will strongly regulate, or close them down, before we can ever allow this to happen,” he said.
Twitter’s decision to fact-check the president’s tweets—and to append a warning label to one—escalated the Trumps’ feud with Silicon Valley.